Serving Bucks County & Montgomery County Pennsylvania

    Doylestown/Yardley Offices

    CALL 215-968-1800 OR USE FORM BELOW


      Hidden Dangers of Dividing Retirements

      Separating and divorcing couples turn to Kevin Zlock’s law firm for an equitable division of retirement assets

      Hidden Dangers of Dividing Retirements

      For many divorcing couples, retirement accounts can represent much of the value of a marital estate. Retirement accounts come in various forms and include Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), Roth IRAs, SEP IRAs, 401(k) plans, 403(b) plans, defined benefit pension plans, etc. Division of these various retirement accounts is a common concern for those separating or going through a divorce. Below are three important issues that arise with respect to retirement assets:

      1. ‘Smart’ Transfers

      Consider the following example. Bob has $100,000 in a 401(k) with his current employer and $50,000 in an IRA. His wife, Mary, has $100,000 in an IRA. Bob and Mary have agreed to divide the retirement accounts equally, so Bob would owe Mary $25,000 from his retirement accounts and offers to transfer these monies from his 401(k), since he has more money in this account. Mary agrees.

      What the parties do not realize is that a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) will be necessary to transfer the $25,000 to Mary. The parties likely will need assistance with preparing the QDRO, which assistance comes with an associated cost; the QDRO must be drafted appropriately in order to avoid tax consequences and effectuate the parties’ intent; and the QDRO preparation and approval process can be lengthy, so Mary might have to wait months to get her money.

      For ease of transfer purposes, Bob should rollover $25,000 from his IRA to Mary’s IRA. A QDRO is not applicable to IRAs and therefore unnecessary for such a rollover, and the parties can accomplish the rollover by providing a separation agreement or copy of their divorce decree, along with letters of instruction, to the financial institution managing Bob’s IRA. Furthermore, the transfer can oftentimes be accomplished within a matter of weeks, as opposed to a matter of months. Absent unique circumstances that would advocate for transferring the monies from Bob’s 401(k), a rollover is the preferred and easier route in such a situation.

      2. Defined Benefit Pension Plans: Pay Now or Pay Later

      In the previous example, we considered retirement accounts with easily determinable present-day cash values. Valuation and division of such accounts is simple when compared to the valuation and division of a defined benefit pension plan. Let us modify the circumstances set forth in the prior example. Mary still has $100,000 in an IRA, but Bob now has a defined benefit pension plan through his present employer.

      Bob worked for this employer for the duration of the parties’ marriage, so the entirety of his pension is marital. Bob is 45 and has worked for his employer for 20 years. Assuming he does not work for his employer any longer and retires in 10 years at age 55, Bob’s monthly benefit payment will be $2,000. Bob proposes to Mary that she keep her IRA and he keep his pension as part of the divorce settlement, assuming that would be an equal division of their retirement assets. This proposal is simple but potentially very unfair.

      Whether or not this is a fair resolution depends on the present value of the pension, which in turns depends on Bob’s life expectancy, the current interest rate, the amount of years until Bob can retire, etc. If an actuary determines that the present value of Bob’s pension is approximately $100,000, then Bob’s proposal is fair and carries out the parties’ intent. If an actuary determines that the present value of Bob’s pension is less than $100,000, then Mary would get the benefit of the bargain based on Bob’s proposal, so to accomplish an equal division, she should rollover a portion of her IRA into an IRA set up for Bob. If an actuary determines that the present value of Bob’s pension is far more than $100,000 (for example, $300,000), then the division becomes slightly more complicated. If the retirement assets are the only assets of substantial value in the marital estate, then Bob cannot afford to pay Mary another $100,000 at this point in time. However, the parties are not without alternatives. Mary can rollover half of her IRA to Bob, and Bob can award Mary 50 percent of the marital portion of his pension monthly pension benefit by way of a QDRO. This proposed distribution would accomplish an equal division of retirement assets in a way that is financially feasible for both parties.

      3. Taxes and Fees

      Regardless of age, parties must pay income tax on distributions from retirement accounts. However, when parties are younger and earning income from employment, the rate of income tax is often higher than when the parties are older and receiving Social Security benefits. Accordingly, if a party is not close to retirement age and needs to take monies out of a retirement account, it is necessary to consider the amount to be paid in income tax. For early distributions, there is a mandatory withholding of 20 percent towards federal income taxes, but remember that this 20 percent is not necessarily sufficient to cover your income tax liability, so you may end up paying extra at tax time.

      There is also the issue of the “early withdrawal penalty.” Generally, if you take a distribution from a retirement account prior to reaching the age of 59 and a half, you will have to pay an additional tax of 10 percent on the amount of the distribution. There may be ways to avoid this 10 percent penalty depending on the circumstances, so structuring the transfer of retirement assets appropriately is a crucial consideration.

      In sum, the division of retirement accounts can be more complex than people realize and may result in both parties incurring unnecessary and avoidable costs and fees. Understanding the various options is important for avoiding these common pitfalls and accomplishing what both parties intend.

      This article appeared in the September 2011 issue of Suburban Life magazine



      Competent and compassionate Bucks County family lawyers

      Child Custody

      Practical, fair and in the best interest of your child


      Child/Spousal Support

      Know the right amount of child and spousal support